Showing posts with label Oneida. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Oneida. Show all posts

Friday, January 30, 2015

Table of Contents



This page provides links to each segment of the article. You may also use the archive list to the left as it lists the entries in the correct order. In addition, you will find links to text that give further information on the article. We will add links to the online versions of the research material, if they are available.

Introduction
Beginning the Journey
The Concept of Perfectionism
American Beginnings
Identification of Perfectionist Tendencies
Early Life of John Humphrey Noyes
Early Life of Jim Jones
Early Life of Vernon Howell
Comparison of Ideologies of the Leaders"
Controlling The Perfect World
End of The Journey
Perfection: The Most Dangerous Kind of Madness
Bibliography


It is important to note that this academic material is copyright-protected. Written authorization is required from the author for any reproduction, quotation, or citation of this work. 
The bibliography is now included at the end of the document. 

Sunday, July 6, 2008

Perfection: The Most Dangerous Kind of Madness

Certain aspects of these groups may have been harmless. Noyes' mutual criticism may have proved helpful to members at times. It is used in psychiatry today in the form of group therapy. The racial unity among Jones' disciples was certainly unsurpassed for the times. The group unity, solidarity, and loyalty achieved by these men says much about the people's ability to work for the common good. Jones did start with some very high ideals and genuinely good efforts. One wonders how could a cooperative system that holds such promise in the proper hands, go so wrong. After looking at the psychological and personal background's and authoritarian ideologies of these leaders, one no longer has to wonder why their congregations self-destructed. One only wonders how so many people could become so blinded to the dangers. Why were so many willing to suffer social stigma or follow to the death men who were obviously disturbed? One answer may be that in the case of Noyes, Jones and Howell, people idolized them. In every commentary about them the phrases are similar. Their word was the Word of God to those who followed them. Hendlin has another answer that seems to be born out in what happened with these communal groups.

"If we can't find our own perfect nature, we seek it in someone else who claims to have found it . . . Seekers fall in love with . . . the image of the perfect. Once they have idealized the leader as perfect, they will psychologically do whatever is necessary to keep him there. But at some point their efforts usually come tumbling down. From perfection, there is nowhere else to go but down -- falling into the everyday world of the imperfect and taking disillusioned disciples with him.

"Rather than see this happen, devoted followers will often ignore abuses of authority . . . inherent contradictions in the group belief system or personal idiosyncrasies of the teacher, minister. . . . [They will] refuse to listen to outsiders who tell them something is wrong, just as they fail to heed their own inner voice that warns them something needs to be questioned." (Hendlin, Steven J. When Good Enough is Never Enough: Escaping the Perfection Trap. New York: G.P. Putnam's Sons, 1992. p. 114 -116)


Our society has taught us to look at perfection as a virtue, so much so that we are now in "pursuit of perfection" rather than of excellence. We fail to see the many "negative and unacknowledged consequences" of this pursuit. People such as Noyes, Jones and Howell are troubled people looking for an ideal. They are equipped with a magnetism that draws others, perhaps less troubled, who are also looking for an ideal. Society has taught them that "practice makes perfect" and many people believe that to be an actuality.

The tragedies at Jonestown and Waco were far more serious than any at Oneida. If such events are to be avoided, we must learn to recognize the perfectionist catalyst. There is a fine line between excellence and perfection. Crossing that line can cause social disruption, psychological and emotional trauma and, in cases such as Jonestown and Waco, death. Seeking a more excellent society is more realistic than longing for a perfect world. Everyone would be well advised to fully understand the difference. "Perfection does not exist; to understand it is the triumph of human intelligence; to expect to possess it is the most dangerous kind of madness." (Tryon Edwards, D.D., et al, The New Dictionary of Thoughts:A Cyclopedia of Quotations. (N.Y.: Standard Book Company, 1955, p. 458. This quote is by Alfred de Musset.)

End of the Journey

Noyes appears to have had more control over his own irrational behavior than Jones and Howell. There is no evidence in the sources used here of any kind of abuse or violence within Oneida. Whenever Noyes is challenged, and there are several times when this occurs, he retreats. Either he backs down from his ideology or he literally retreats to another location. In the end he retreats to an isolated spot and doesn't come back. Perhaps the fact that both Jones and Howell move their communal groups to different locations over a period of years indicates they were running too. The question remains, were they running to or away from something?

Maybe an inner voice in all these men whispered that there was something wrong. They could hear the voice that pointed out their flaws but not the one that told them they were on the wrong path. Their own inflated egos would not let them admit to any failure or misdirection within themselves. Others failed to hear the voice or if they heard it, they failed to heed it. Reiterman says, " . . . despite the many signals to the contrary, those closest to Jones had failed to realize he had no intention of permitting his movement to survive him." There is an indication of the same thing in the comments made by Howell and already mentioned, that if he were killed he would come back. Regarding the People's Temple, "We'll all die tonight. . .but father will raise us up tomorrow." Did Jones and Howell intend their movements to end in death? Probably not, although there is reason to speculate. Noyes probably never considered leaving his group. However, they each started a journey with a destination in mind. Unfortunately, it never occurred to any of them that it wasn't a real place.

Controlling the Perfect World

Noyes, Jones and Howell all formed communal groups. Whether they believed this was the way to run a better world or whether they knew it was a good way to control a large number of people will never be known for certain. However, each man used effective control mechanism to maintain a tight rein on the members.

A close reading of the material on Noyes suggests a positive environment but much of this could be biased since relatives wrote it. Nothing in the sources suggests that either Jonestown or the Davidian compound were positive environments. They may have begun as one but they certainly did not remain so.

All the groups had a common purse. Everyone turned over their property to the group or sold it and gave the proceeds to the group. All had either created or invested in businesses or worked for other people.

Communal housing in each case was usually constructed over time after the group had already formed. In Oneida each member had his own private room or shared one with another. Genders were separated. Childcare and dining were also communal and education was provided for all, men, women and children. Apparently, the members were educated, had some financial means and were white. Noyes did participate in the abolitionist group, New Haven Antislavery Society in 1832-3 but there is no indication of black members at Oneida. There were a variety of entertainments, dancing, theatricals, games of all kinds, picnics and musicals. Certainly, it sounds like heaven and very different from Jonestown and Waco.

Jonestown's communal housing was not so well planned. Before going to South America they converted houses and donated property into communal dwellings. Once in Jonestown everything was not as the brochures portrayed. Cottages for eight to ten held fourteen; instead of free time after work there were "catharsis sessions and long rambling discourses by . . . Jones." There was none of the social events as in Oneida. These sessions went on for hours and everything from personality, to sexual problems, to business matters were discussed. There were mandatory Soviet propaganda films with exams following. There were also suicide drills every two weeks. What people did, where they went and who they saw was decided by Jones. Parents and relatives whose family members belonged to the commune were prevented from seeing them.

The Davidian commune was more similar to Jonestown in structure but the members of this group were amazingly educated people. There were doctors, lawyers, nurses and computer specialist to name a few. There were some black people but unlike Jones, Howell was an extreme racist. His ideas on the sexual differences are quite extraordinary and more than a little disgusting. In Jonestown the people were 75% black, 25% white, and/or senior citizens on Social Security. The Davidian com-pound was constructed by the members and supported by the members at outside jobs or donations from wealthy members in other areas. They also started several businesses. Families were separated. Men, women and children were housed separately. The women Howell chose for wives had a special dormitory or half a dozen could be in his room at any one time. There were diet restrictions that changed according to Howell's whims and visions; he became obsessed with various food. Entertainment, in the form of music or film, was dictated by Howell. He would spend hours playing loud music to a captive audience.

Noyes, Jones, and Howell all abolish marriage. Noyes made this his doctrine from the beginning. There is no marriage in Oneida; everyone is married to everyone else. Noyes believed that there would be no marriage in heaven and therefore to set up the New Kingdom must be done away with. He believed it was possible to love many people and that sexual exclusiveness was a sin. Jones and Koresh began this practice much later in their groups, however, they did not exactly get rid of traditional marriage.

Jones abolished and arranged marriages. At one point, he encouraged "members to share sexual favors freely." Conventional sexual mores and jealousies he denounced as egotistical and hypocritical. However, he changed sexual mores as it suited him. He not only took the wives of his members, but had sex with the men in the church. In fact, Jones considered himself the only heterosexual in the group. Everyone else had homosexual desires and tendencies. Near the end of the group’s existence Jones set up a Relationships Committee. Rules for sex and marriage were created and committee approval was needed to form a union.

As for Howell, he also took the wives of his members and like Jones fathered several children by them. In Howell's group there were even problems of venereal diseases. He told his members that only he could produce "righteous children" and that God had given all their wives to him first.

All three groups have an interest in children. Oneida introduces stirpiculture in an attempt to create a spiritually superior people. Jones promoted a "rainbow family" to symbolize brotherhood, using adoption to create multiracial families. Howell wanted to raise an army of God from his own seed. He also forbade contact between the children and their natural fathers within the commune.

Criticism was used by all three groups, as well. The faults of an individual were aired in a group setting and ways of improvement were supposed to be recommended by the group. This is not supposed to be a malicious or vindictive effort but to help the person being criticized. Jones and Howell both made these experiences deliberately unpleasant by exposing personal and embarrassing information about members. The leaders are never subject to criticism. According to themselves, Noyes was God's lieutenant, Jones was God, and Howell was Jesus Christ.

Comparison of Ideologies of the Leaders

John Humphrey Noyes gained followers from other Perfectionist groups as well as other religions. Whether they truly believed Noyes' teaching or whether they were simply drawn to the man's magnetism is a debatable question. A few of the elements of his theology have already been mentioned. Besides believing that Christ had already returned, Noyes believed that the "judgment of the world would be a gradual spiritual operation effected by truth and invisible power without any regard of the physical machinery which alarms the imaginations of most expectants of the great day." To Noyes it would be a steady, step-by-step process to perfection. The law no longer applied because those who are perfect are above the law. It was his job to set up the Kingdom of Heaven on Earth. Noyes felt he was "primary recipient of inspiration and grace" and everyone had to be subordinate to his will. As far as can be found, Noyes never claimed more than lieutenant status to God.

Jim Jones, a Methodist minister, to some extent shared this belief. Jones searched for the perfect church but, unlike Noyes, he wasn't really looking for religion per se. He wanted a world where there was no poverty, security for the aged, collective bargaining, free speech, prison reform, jobs for all and racial equality and he wanted to be in charge. His utopia was more along Marxist lines than God's. In fact he quotes Marx ". . . from each according to his ability to each according to his need." Socialism is the watchword for the People's Temple.

Where Noyes won people by preaching of his gospel, Jones won people with good deeds, miracles, and socialist ideals of equality cloaked in Christianity. He took in foster children and raised money for special projects. "Jones wanted to shelter the needy, to provide a family for the lonely. Stray animals and people were taken in." He took neighborhood children to the zoo, opened a soup kitchen, gave away canned goods, paid rent for the indigent, and gave away clothing. The list goes on but this would appear to be Christianity as it was meant to be.

Jim Jones inspires it all. Often he reached into his own pocket to help street beggars and the needy. But before he gave a substantial sum to anyone, he had his aides investigate to make sure the person deserved it. If Jones saw a need, he tried to fill it. A benevolent opportunist, efficient, savvy, businesslike, he was the sort of preacher who could convince the owners of the synagogue he bought to loan the money interest-free if it were repaid within a year -- and who would satisfy the debt one day early. (Reiterman, Tim & John Jacobs, Raven: The Untold Story of the Rev. Jim Jones and His People. (New York: E.P. Dutton) 1982. p.54)


There is no indication that Oneida or the Davidians made such massive efforts to win and convert so many people. Jones and Howell both had political connections. Howell's were only local people but Jones lobbied in Washington with Senators and Congressmen. Later in Jonestown foreign leaders, such as Russian Ambassador Feodor Timofeyev, visited.

Vernon Howell differed from Noyes and Jones in that he took over an existing group whose belief system was already established and that had an established membership. Howell at first took a subordinate position in the group but eventually claimed divine inspiration. At God's command he began an affair with the seventy year old Lois Rodin. Howell claimed to be a prophet and challenged the claim to leadership of Lois Rodin's son, George. The Seventh Day Adventist have a strong belief in prophecy and prophets. It is the group belief in prophecies that allows Howell to make such radical changes in doctrine.

The basic belief of the Davidian's was that Biblical prophecies spoke of a latter day David who would appear and lead the church into the Kingdom of God. This "modern day David would have to be a prophet . . . . ." The Church would be obligated to follow him while God slaughtered all unbelievers. In the final days of the Waco tragedy, Howell, calling himself Koresh, alluded to this slaughter as part of his Seven Seals. Like Noyes, he believes he would not die or if he did he would be resurrected.

Early Life of Vernon Howell

Vernon Howell was born out-of-wedlock to 14 year-old Bonnie Clark in 1959. Ironically, his father was a carpenter. His mother gave him to her mother and sister to raise. For the next several years he thought his aunt was his mother. In 1964 his mother married, came to get her son and moved to Texas. He had learning disabilities that he later called dyslexia. The school placed Howell in a special education setting. Others teased him. Once, he was raped by several boys.

In spite of his learning disabilities, by the age of twelve Howell had memorized the New Testament. He found peace and escaped the bullies by attending church. According to Clifford Linedecker, "he could pick out a phrase, a sentence, or a word . . . and discuss the esoteric and meaning for twenty minutes -- or for hours." This same talent in addition to his knowledge of scripture made it easy for him to take control of the Branch Davidians in the 1980's. The history of the Davidians also made the take over a simple task. The Davidians split from the Seventh Day Adventist in 1930 when Victor Houteff was disfellowshipped after he declared that he had been "selected by God to cleanse the church of hypocrites and false believers."

At twelve, Howell found his niche. He was fast on his feet and immediately became a fanatic in sports. He became obsessed with his strength. He once wrestled another person fourteen times until he won. The more success Howell had in sports the more popular he became and this made him more arrogant and patronizing. Now he had what it took to attract girls. After quitting school in the ninth grade, Howell found church the ideal spot to find the kind of girl he wanted. He had many girlfriends and at 19, an illegitimate child that he never saw.

Howell believed he had a "special and unique relationship with God" one minute and that he was "'a worthless son of a bitch, scum who was so evil that he was amazed God didn't strike him dead on the spot.'" Howell described it this way. "Sometimes I was so scared I couldn't eat, and my bowels became so bound up that I used to have to reach in there and with my hand and remove my waste that way."

Just as Noyes and Jones before him had struggled with their own inadequacy, so too did Howell. Howell was obsessed with sex. He refers to it frequently in his Bible class. He felt terrible guilt over his compulsive masturbation. He even discussed it with his pastor who advised him to pray. When he realized no relief, he decided to leave the Southern Baptist Church and turned to the Seventh-day Adventist.

Just as Noyes had an obsession with Abigail Merwin and used scripture to back up his belief in multiple partners, Howell had a vision regarding the pastor's daughter. Afterward, he read Isaiah 31:15-16 and used this scripture to claim that God had given him the pastor's daughter as his wife. Even though he was forbidden to see the girl, he continued to relate his vision and press the issue in the church. As a result, he was thrown out of the Seventh-day Adventist Church in 1981 and straight into the arms of the Branch Davidian leader, Lois Rodin the leader of the Branch Davidians.

It was necessary to look at the lives of Noyes, Jones, and Howell to understand what started them on their journey. There are many other telling events and behaviors they share which are too numerous to mention here. The preceding sections ended at the point when these men began to form their groups. We must also look at each man's utopian idea and the similar means each used as the leader of their communal group.

Early Life of Jim Jones

Born in Indiana in 1931, Jim Jones came from a very different background than Noyes but with evidently similar personality traits and perfectionist views. An only child, his parents, James T. Jones and Lynetta, were poor. A sixteen year age difference separated the two. Jim's father was a disabled veteran who worked hard labor jobs when he was able. His mother was a smoking, cursing, beer drinking factory worker educated in business and finance. Lynetta was the breadwinner while James spent most of his time in a rocker listening to the radio. She was active in the labor union movement and came to be "regarded as a troublemaker."

Lynetta was the "dominate force" in her son's life. From her he inherited the "canny aggressiveness . . . general irreverence toward the world . . . and a certain self-righteousness and grandiosity that allowed him to see himself as an independent spirit proudly pushing against the prevailing flows of society." Jones view of a society filled with injustice came from his mother.

The close ties of the Noyes family, and of most other depression era families, are absent in the Jones family. His parents did not go to PTA meetings, school plays, church or even share a bed. There was no real supervision for young Jim and when he was a junior in high school his parents divorced. He often went around dirty and half naked. For company, he always had dozens of stray dogs and cats following him and would take them everywhere. He spent hours training, talking to and playing with them. As a result, neighborhood children were drawn to Jones and he managed to get them to do the chores he didn't want to do, such as feeding and cleaning the animals. Jones, like Noyes, seemed to be a natural leader of children, and throughout their lives and that of Howell, children play a central part.

Very early, Jones learned to manipulate people. He had an ability to hold the attention of his small male followers for hours and was always the leader. He preached, talked, and scolded. There were even "ritualistic" funerals for the pets when they died. He claimed special power, and authority, and brooked no challenge to that authority. Among his playmates, Jones developed his ability to "structure the environment" to control people, developing a "genius" for moving from playmate to dominate and "pushing his authority then backing off." He often did outrageous things to see how people would react.

Jones was introduced to the Nazarene church by a neighbor, Myrtle Kennedy, worried about the small boy and attracted to his charming looks. Soon, Jones began his wanderings from church to church. He had begun his search for the "perfect" church. It was in his contact with the Pentecostal church that he received the closeness and warmth he craved "from the most despised rejects of the community."

Like Polly Noyes, Lynetta Jones had high hopes for her son. She wanted Jim to be a success. She gave up the opportunity to stay at home with him to make sure he could have a college education. She worked everyday at an out-of-town job and saved every penny. "Don't you be nothing like your dad. . . . You have to make something of your life and be somebody. Work at it. Nobody's gonna help you."

He did work at it. Jones became a good student, dated nice girls and a was voracious reader ". . . continuing an earlier pattern of reading widely . . . he studied religion, medicine, and world affairs." He was many things to many people; an innocent to Mrs. Kennedy, a recluse on the playground, at the garage and on the street a "holy terror," and in the neighborhood a "roguish little natural leader."

Jones became obsessed with cleanliness and his appearance. He hated physical activities that would get him sweaty or dirty, preferring mental pursuits. He bathed regularly at a time when the Saturday night bath was the norm for people who rarely had indoor plumbing. Every hair had to be in place, his clothes immaculate and his shoes polished. Until the end, Jones continued to be obsessed with his appearance.

Gradually, Jones' small followers grew up and found sports. Jones turned to more spiritual pursuits, criticizing the alternative pursuits of his past friends as either immoral or a waste of time. Jones sought other followers in neighbors, or pedestrians. For a time he sported white robes when he went out. Later he realized he had to tone down his religious fervor if he were to convince people of his sincerity, and his sanity.

Jones began his studies at Indiana University in 1948. He was dating Marceline Baldwin, the woman he would eventually marry. She was training for a career in nursing and was a dedicated Christian. Jones met Marceline when they both worked in the same hospital, he as an orderly. He managed to win her parents over in a few visits, particularly when he told them he was active in a church in Lynn. However, Jones was distant with his fellow students. During discussions of theology he answered their theology questions only by quoting scripture without discussing the issues. He felt their attitudes were frivolous and indulgent and their lifestyles disgusted him. Jones saw himself as superior to the other students just as he had with his playmates. However, his attempts to get reactions from people were more malicious now. One night he stuck a pin through the upper bunk mattress of his roommate.

In 1949, Jones married Marceline Baldwin. They lived near the University and continued their educations but the glow began to fade when Jones began to express atheistic views. Jones eventually demanded that Marceline give up praying. Her refusal brought threats of suicide from Jones but she continued. Jim also demanded she deny her faith and accept his. From this point on Jones' behavior becomes more erratic. "Unkind one minute, Jim could turn almost saintly the next. He could counsel and expound on the most serious subjects, then suddenly behave like a mischievous little boy."

Jones' former relations with Marceline's family also changed after an instance of sabotage to their automobile aroused family suspicions that he was guilty. He once told Marceline a dear friend was killed in a car wreck, simply to see how much she cared for her friend. These are the beginning of many such accidents. Eventually, poison will become a key part of Jones methods of control and fear. Reiterman says such incidences were to test the loyalty of others. Jones needed to know he was the center of everyone's world.

In 1952 Jim Jones made the move that would have devastating results twenty-eight years later. Perhaps he had been preparing for it all his life. Perhaps it was a sudden decision brought on by all the injustices he believed were in the world. Nowhere had he found a church that could measure up to his standards. Jim Jones decided to enter the ministry. He could fix everything.

Early Life of John Humphrey Noyes

First, we will consider how these elements played out in the life and perfectionist religious movement of John Humphrey Noyes. He came from well-to-do parents living in Battleboro, Vermont in 1811 and was one of nine children. His father, a teacher turned businessman, was later in politics and his mother was the aunt of Rutherford B. Hayes. While his father ". . .respected the Bible and Christianity [and] was a vigorous moralist," he followed no particular religion. Noyes' mother was very devout. There are no documents concerning Noyes childhood but one source says he was "a precocious learner and thoughtful." He would go to bed early to think. He also had a quick temper and was "a natural leader among the children." Noyes entered college at age fifteen to study law.

The family was close-knit. Letters in G.W. Noyes book, The Religious Experience of John Humphrey Noyes show a loving, concerned family. John later converted several family members to his perfectionist doctrines. Actually, it is probably from both parents that Noyes learned his perfectionist behaviors, but the differing religious emphasis must have caused him stress. A letter from his father while John was away at school told him to get rid of any notion that would prevent him from attaining a "lofty mark." According to G.W. Noyes, John's mother, Polly ". . . no sooner saw a principle than she must attempt to realize it in practice. The shortcomings revealed by introspection were always a cause of suffering to her, yet religious assurance was a prominent characteristic." Once the family waited three months to move while she prayed for divine direction.

Polly Noyes had high hopes for her son. From the beginning he was, in her mind, special. A "'proper child'" she wrote. Her dream and prayer was that he "become a minister of the everlasting gospel." It is at her urging that Noyes attended the revival meeting in 1831 where he was converted. Actually, this was not his first conversion experience or his last. He said he went to please her but resisted his call on the grounds he would have to give up law and "Satan frequently suggested . . . I should live to see the millennium. . ." It isn't until he got a cold that he began to consider the "uncertainty of life" and his need for salvation.

Although Noyes admitted that he was not comfortable with the "phrenzy" of religion, his contemplation of death was the impetus he needed. Like his mother, he began his religious life with a passion. There are frequent mentions of "darkness" and self-criticism because he did not feel deserving of God's grace. By 1832 he was experiencing great depression. He felt guilt over things he did as a boy and he always worried about his flaws. Noyes felt he was unattractive and didn't relate well to people, particularly women. Noyes' biographer, Robert Thomas says he was "constantly preoccupied with his appearance, dress, speech, and moral behavior." There are several comments in Noyes writings that indicate this preoccupation with his shortcomings and the biting criticism he is capable of regarding others' shortcomings. His criticism of others increases over time, especially after he declared himself perfect during a sermon in 1833 that lost him his license to preach in the Presbyterian Church. He was twenty-three years old.

Noyes had his New York experience in 1834. He found himself in deep and repeated conflict with the major religious leaders of his day such as Charles Finney. It didn't matter who they were, if they disagreed with Noyes they were wrong. He lost many of his friends and associates. Whitworth says that the rejection and isolation heightened Noyes' belief that he was the "sole possessor of an understanding of true Christianity . . . [and he was] God's lieutenant. . . ." Even more arrogant statements would be made over a hundred years later by Jones and Howell. "Plagued by his own self-doubts, his theories derided by others, deserted by Theodore Weld, another man troubled by carnal desires, and his funds dwindling rapidly, Noyes suffered through his most prolonged and severe depression. . . ." He appears to have reached a point at which he experienced a breakdown and questioned everything he believed, even to the point of denying there was a God. He ate and slept little during this period, mainly because he was afraid of his dreams. He describes having trouble eating and sleeping during this time. Certain foods, such as "animal foods" suddenly became a taboo while "marine foods" were acceptable. After three weeks he went home to be cared for by his family and to tell everyone who would listen of his experience. Gradually, Noyes came to see this as a testing period in which he could prove himself worthy.

Noyes' ideal was to pattern his life after Christ. He began to spend more time in prayer and Bible study. By 1833 he boasts of twelve to sixteen hours of Bible reading a day and three hours a day in prayer. Obviously, he had little time for anything else. He also mentions " . . . temperance, fasting, [and] exercise . . . " as a means to overcome aliments. One can only speculate as to the effects of all this on his mental and physical health. In his own words Noyes says, "Many times and for days together my heart was so burdened with spiritual joy, that my body became weak and pined away."

Noyes had developed the doctrine that the second coming of Christ had occurred in A.D. 70 and that he was living "in the age of the fulfillment of Christ's prophecies . . . " He now believed that he would see the millennium and even be the catalyst for its start, even though he thought the idea came from Satan. It is from this belief that all of his most radical doctrines evolved.

His belief in multiple marriage or as he termed it, complex marriage caused even more storm than his declaration of perfection. Noyes fell in love with one of his earliest converts, Abigail Merwin. Even after she married, he claimed that she was his wife because she was given to him by God and that fact transcended the bonds of worldly matrimony. This rejection may have been a catalyst for Noyes forming his complex marriage ideas. He felt guilty over sexual feelings, particularly when she was a convert. He also seemed to want more than one sexual partner and did not know how to deal with his carnal desires. During the next several years Noyes distributed his more radical beliefs in a publication, The Perfectionist, he started with a friend. His own paper was called, The Witness. Through his preaching and these publications Noyes gathers the core for his communal experiment from his converts.

Identification of Perfectionist Tendencies

One should keep in mind that Hendlin says "hard core perfectionist have obsessive-compulsive tendencies." In fact, obsessions are a chief sign of perfectionism and fall into three categories. First, "a preoccupation on religious or spiritual concerns regarding the purpose or meaning of one's life, ultimate destiny, death, suffering, or evil." This can be accompanied by brooding, depression, and pessimism. The second involves phobias or inhibiting obsessions, such as fear of flying, washing things a certain number of times, guilt over sexual feelings, and obsession with being perfectly dressed. Third, impulsive obsession or compulsive behavior. According to Hendlin "Compulsions are obsessions in action." The obsessive develops an "overly sever, self-punishing moral conscience." Again, the motivating factor for the perfectionist is control, of his thoughts, feelings, and actions.

Hendlin gives a list of disorders that are created and aggravated by the perfectionist personality. They are evident sign posts scattered throughout the lives of Noyes, Jones, and Howell. Eating disorders, manic-depressive mood disorder, obsessive-compulsive disorder and the need to control others all show themselves. Feelings of specialness, entitlement, and self-absorption, emptiness, lack of personal and spiritual meaning in life, cosmetic surgical procedures that can cause pain and disfigurement, even serious injury to the body are often apparent. Guilt, envy, jealousy, inordinate desire for power, fame and status, substance abuse, physical problems such as high blood pressure, poor digestion, skin disorders, sleep disorders, and various stress-related illnesses may appear. Loneliness, withdrawal, and depression can result.

American Beginnings

Strong religious impulses and revivals in the early 1800's in America gave rise to many new groups, even denominations, which were diverse in many areas of doctrine but often focusing on perfection as a means of achieving a better world. A surprising number of those involved formed communes and their efforts led to many positive changes in society. Unfortunately, there have been others with perfectionist ideals who have left mostly negative effects in their wake.

One hypothesis suggests that communal experiments formed during stressful times. Michael Barkun describes the period from 1810 to the 1840's as filled with economic collapse, natural disasters, and changes in family structure. These combined to place enormous stress on people and forced them to try to seek explanations. During this time they began to consider disastrous events as signs of the end-time.

Reaction to stress seemed to play a part in the formation of Oneida, the People's Temple and the Branch Davidians. Oneida formed in the wake of the spiritual revival in New England that resulted from the events Barkun relates. Jim Jones began to gather his followers during the social upheaval of the 1950's and 1960's. Vernon Howell took over the Davidians during problems within the group in the 1970's. However, if one looks at the leaders, it becomes apparent that they were under enormous personal tension, both emotional and intellectual. These stressed, perfectionist individuals then initiated communal living as the perfect form for their followers. Each leader's early experiences made him not only a perfectionist in philosophy but in character. Each wanted a better world but could not help escaping to try to reach it. Each found it necessary to attract disciples to give them the status they craved. Noyes retreated altogether by giving up the leadership of the commune. Jones committed suicide after years of growing paranoia. Howell's belief in his own divinity and invincibility lead to his death in an underground bunker, an eerily familiar scenario of another probable perfectionist, Adolph Hitler. In fact, Noyes, Jones, and Howell share traits very evident in Hitler's life. Striking background similarities also exists between Jones and Howell .

The Concept of Perfectionism

To understand men such as Noyes, Jones and Howell, it is necessary to understand the concept of perfectionism and its origins. Why do we have this idea of the perfect? Why would anyone aspire to or believe in the possibility of a perfect world? In short, what is perfectionism and is there something else besides a religious belief at the root of this concept?

Perfectionism may be defined as ". . .any doctrine that holds that moral, religious, or social perfection can and should be attained in this life." Perfect suggests ". . .the extreme degree of excellence according to a given standard."

Certain psychologists believe the concept of perfection is innate. "Jung and Freud believed we have an intuitive and instinctive knowledge of the perfect and the flawed." Jung called the idea of perfection part of the ". . . unconscious, universal images that are part of the inherited nature of the psyche and represent common human needs, instincts, and potentials." Our idea of perfection is a yardstick by which we measure everything else. Everyone has some perfectionist traits. This doesn't normally pose a problem unless one can't discern the difference between the ability to conceive of perfection and real world behavior.

Many people throughout history have tried to achieve perfection. Writers, such as Plato and Sir Thomas More, wrote very detailed accounts regarding their idea of a perfect society. Hundreds of books have been written concerning factual and fictional accounts of attempts of the perfect world or Utopia. Perfectionism in American theological doctrine and religious teachings began with the writings of Englishman John Wesley. J.A. Wood's Christian Perfection as Taught by John Wesley suggests that Wesley's idea of Christian perfection was not a "behavioral compliance with an absolute standard of perfection" but a changing of inner attitudes and motives. To Wesley, only God was completely infallible and sinlessly perfect. In the last 200 years this idea has changed. For many religious groups perfection is equated with salvation. Only by becoming perfect in every way in this life can one attain salvation and be fit to reign in a new kingdom with Christ.

Beginning the Journey

The premise presented here is that, while the ideologies and methods employed by these leaders reflect the concept of perfectionism, it is the learned behavior of their perfectionist personalities that lead them along the paths they took. The evidence shown here suggests that we may be born with the ability to conceive of perfectionism but that perfectionists are made, not born. Steven Hendlin points out in When Good Enough is Never Enough, "Our culture . . . encourages perfectionism" and in their search for perfection there are those who are "unable to control the direction their strivings take them . . ." In spite of several background differences, John Humphrey Noyes, Jim Jones and Vernon Howell all exhibit perfectionist tendencies early in their lives. Perfectionism is a destination, one that can never be reached. By looking at the personal lives of these three men we can witness their journey to nowhere.

Introduction

This paper deals with the perfectionist characteristics of the leaders of Oneida, Jonestown, and the Branch Davidian communes. John Humphrey Noyes, Jim Jones and Vernon Howell made attempts to create their version of a perfect world based on the ideals of perfectionism. Each of these men had a basic religious theology that he radically changed to fit his own needs. Each man gathered a following and withdrew from society. Each one was able enjoin his followers to accept the radical practices despite outside pressures. All three men appear to have been either emotionally or mentally unstable most of their lives. There were several methods that were used by all three men as means of control. Control is what these men seek all their lives. For Noyes, Jones and Howell control is the key to perfection.

Thanks for Visiting!

I appreciate the time you spent here and invite you to visit the other blogs show in the header.